U.S. District Court Ruling Could Allow State Wildlife Agencies to Kill 460 Federally Protected California Sea Lions in Washington and Oregon
There is a court case currently taking place which could have a serious impact on the future protection of endangered and threatened species in the US. The Humane Society of the United States and the Wild Fish Conservancy have filed a complaint and a temporary restraining order (TRO) against the National Marine Fisheries Services (NMFS). This action follows a decision by the NMFS to allow State Wildlife Agencies to kill up to 460 federally protected California sea lions over the next five years. The restraining order was denied this morning in US District Court. The court will allow the NMFS to kill California Sea Lions while waiting for the full case to be heard.
The Humane Society shared these main points from the court proceedings this morning:
- The court denied the temporary restraining order
- The number of sea lions which can be killed has been temporarily lowered from 90 to 30
- The court requires the sea lions to be killed by euthanasia
- The court felt the issues raised were important and the case will continue on all merits
- The Humane Society is confident they will prevail
These are the facts surrounding this issue:
- The Marine Mammal Protection Act protects sea lions in the United States.
- Some California Sea Lions have chosen the Bonneville Dam on the Columbia River as their feeding grounds. The dam is located about 40 miles east of Portland, Oregon.
- Several groups of people in Washington, Oregon, and Idaho want to blame these sea lions for “taking their fish” and have used the sea lion as a scapegoat, even though the amount of salmon caught by these sea lions equals approximately only 1%.
- On behalf of these groups, the states of Oregon, Washington, and Idaho petitioned the US National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) to grant them authority to kill the sea lions. This group has lost prior cases in court, but managed to kill sea lions before the rulings took place. A new application was submitted on their behalf on August 18, 2011, once again requesting authority to lethally remove individually identifiable California sea lions seen eating salmon at Bonneville Dam. On March 15, 2012, NMFS again granted the states’ request, authorizing state agents to kill as many as 92 federally protected California sea lions each year for 5 years – a total of 460 animals.
- The slaughter was set to begin on March 19, however the Humane Society of the United States, the Wild Fish Conservancy, and two individuals filed for a temporary restraining order in US District Court in Washington, DC.
Scott West, Director of Intelligence and Investigations for Sea Shepherd Conservation Society had the following to say about the issue:
“The fact is that human activity is destroying fish populations. The construction of dams, the activity of fish farming, the introduction of non-native species, the discharge of pollutants, sport fishing, rigid treaty fishing rights, and mechanized commercial fishing operations contribute to catastrophic failure of fish species. These are all human activities and have been increasing in recent years along with the human population on the planet. What IS normal is the predation of fish by other fish, by birds, by sharks, and by marine mammals. Predation is far older than the presence of humans on the planet. Subsistence and artisanal fishing (predation) by humans has been around a long time and for the most part has been able to coexist with the natural order. Pinning the blame elsewhere and drawing attention away from the real culprit(s) are common human behaviors. The scapegoat is nothing new. Seals, sea lions, and dolphins have been blamed the world over through ignorance and greed for the collapse of fish stocks when the real reasons (human activity) are ignored. Using marine mammals as scapegoats knows no race, cultural, or nationalistic limits. Canadians, Chileans, Japanese, and yes even folks in the USA participate,”
Although sea lions do eat fish, they only consume between 0.4% and 4.2% of the 80,000 to 300,000 salmon that spawn in the Columbia River each year. The following list based on NMFS estimates shows the percentages for salmon takes in the Columbia River:
- The dams along the Columbia River take up to 60% of juvenile salmon and up to 17% of adult salmon.
- Human fishing activity takes approximately 16% of the adult salmon from the river.
- Non-native, introduced sport-fishing species consume up to 3 million young salmon a year.
- Birds eat up to 18%
- Sea lions take roughly 1%
- In addition, by-catch of Columbia River salmon in open ocean fisheries contributes to the loss of Columbia River salmon.
Based on this information (and common sense) it is clear that the sea lions are not the real problem.
Salmon runs vary on a yearly basis and scientists are predicting a large run this year in the Columbia River. Yet the states still want to kill the scapegoat. “Few people want to look for the real reasons fish populations are declining because doing so will require them to look in the mirror,” said Scott West.
There is a war being waged against the United States’ environmental protection efforts. There are groups and forces that are attempting to dismantle the very laws that have been put in place to improve and protect the quality of the air, water, and soil in the US and against the laws that have allowed several species to return from the brink of extinction. This issue could very well be a starting point to return the US to a time when it was common and legal to kill marine mammals (and other creatures) which “get in the way” of human enterprise. This is a critical time for our world’s ecosystems and many of animal species. Our laws should be providing extra protection for our environment, not diminishing the small amount of safeguards which already exist.
Sea Shepherd cannot ignore this slaughter-which might soon occur on the U.S.’s doorstep. We are currently offering a reward for information leading to the arrest of the person or persons responsible for shooting sea lions in the Puget Sound. With the Bonneville Dam temporary restraining order not being granted and the full lawsuit coming up, we will need to bring this issue to the forefront. The Humane Society has been in this fight for some time and we are happy to offer help. We have experience with documenting senseless slaughter. Perhaps we will need to institute a “Dam Guardian” campaign at the Bonneville Dam. How many volunteers would be willing to come to the dam and help? Stay tuned.