Commentary by Paul Watson
Sea Shepherd Conservation Society

This editorial is posted with the permission of Henry Mark Holzer and the San Diego Union Tribune. It is an important article because intervention by the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society in this issue has been motivated by our concern that the San Diego City Council will be in violation of Federal law, specifically the Marine Mammal Protection Act. Some critics have argued that this is a local issue. Our position is that it is a national issue. The Sea Shepherd Conservation Society is committed to defending the integrity of the Federal Marine Mammal Protection Act.

The Children's Pool and the Law

By Henry Mark Holzer
October 19, 2004


Posted at:
www.signonsandiego.com/uniontrib/20041019/news_lz1e19holzer.html

1931 - State of California grants the land at the Children's Pool "to be devoted exclusively to public park, bathing pool for children."
- Web site of Councilman Scott Peters, San Diego District 1

It is this erroneous statement - by an "environmental" lawyer who has misquoted a state statute - that is at the core of a new lawsuit seeking to save the La Jolla seals and habitat from destruction by this city.

In virtually every discussion about the controversy, reference is made to a "Children's Pool." This mischaracterization has been used to create the impression Ellen Browning Scripps wanted Casa Beach used exclusively for children.

But Scripps did not give the city any property to create a "children's pool." On the contrary, it was the state, not Scripps, that conveyed beach property to the city - but not for the sole purpose of creating a pool for children.

Chapter 937 of the Laws of 1931 is entitled: "An act granting certain tide and submerged lands of the state of California to the city of San Diego, San Diego County, in said state, upon certain trusts and conditions."

Section 1(a) of the statute states in full: "That said lands shall be devoted exclusively to (1) public park, (2) bathing pool for children, (3) parkway, (4) highway, (5) playground and (6) recreational purposes and (7) to such other uses as may be incident to, or convenient for the full enjoyment of, such purposes."

Of the six specifically enumerated uses, at least three are extremely broad: (3) parkway, (4) highway and (6) recreational purposes. Certainly, the latter could mean almost anything, from amusement parks to movie theaters to athletic fields - or, surely, as has been the case for decades, seal-watching.

It is No. 7 - "such other uses" - that even more belies the anti-seal propaganda that has labeled Casa Beach as a "Children's Pool." The meaning and scope of the "such other uses" power is left entirely up to the city under its home-rule power, granted by the state constitution.

Thus, no matter what Peters, other anti-seal partisans, or the uninformed, may call Casa Beach, it was never intended to be exclusively a "Children's Pool." It has not been exclusively a "Children's Pool." It is not now. And there is nothing in history, law or public policy that mandates it should be.

It was only after the statutory conveyance of Casa Beach from the state to the city that Scripps donated the sea wall. Her wishes then - even if clearly expressed, and well intentioned - could no more amend Chapter 937 of the laws of 1931 than can the constant and erroneous mantra-like mischaracterization of Casa Beach as the "Children's Pool."

The time has long passed to lay this dangerous mischaracterization to rest, and to prevent the supposedly animal-friendly city of San Diego from using the "Children's Pool" label as an excuse to dredge Casa Beach - and to destroy the only seal rookery between Carpenteria and Mexico (one recognized but unprotected by the federal government). This is why our Save The San Diego Seals Coalition has challenged the city's dredging decision.

Essentially, we make two claims.

The first is that the city of San Diego has failed, and even refused, to enforce Municipal Code Section 63.0102(b)(10), which makes it "unlawful" for anyone "within any public ... beach areas within the city of San Diego" to "disturb, or maltreat any bird or animal, either wild or domesticated. ... "

Testament to the city's egregious disregard of its own ordinance is the fact that at least two seals were knifed to death at Casa Beach during the past two weeks alone.

Our second claim is that the dredging of Casa Beach will violate California Code of Civil Procedure Section 526(a), providing that a judgment may be sought "restraining and preventing any illegal expenditure of, waste of, or injury to, the ... funds ... of a . .. city. ... "

As to Section 526(a)'s "expenditure" requirement, the city has estimated that its dredging plan will cost hundreds of thousands of dollars. Ultimately, however, as with all municipal projects, it will cost considerably more - especially since the city has not been dissuaded from its folly by one of the world's leading experts on beach erosion.

n 1999, Douglas Inman informed the city that moving the sand will not only fail to cure the purported problems at Casa Beach, but will cause serious additional problems - including undermining the cliffs and the property that sits atop them.

As to Section 526(a)'s requirement that the expenditure be "illegal," it is a violation of the city's own ordinance to harm the seals at Casa Beach. Further, it is a crime under the federal Marine Mammal Protection Act for anyone - including the city of San Diego - to "harass" any marine mammal. The Marine Mammal Protection Act defines "harass" to include any act of pursuit or annoyance having the potential to injure or disturb a marine mammal by causing disruption of behavioral patterns, including but not limited to migration, breathing, nursing, breeding, feeding or sheltering. One need not be an expert to know that when the city moves onto Casa Beach with its bulldozers, dump trucks, diesel engines, jackhammers and other heavy equipment required to excavate hundreds of tons of sand, the seals will, at the very least, be "harassed."

In the name of what, then, does the city of San Diego propose - illegally, and in violation of its own animal protection ordinance - to destroy the habitat of a federally recognized, and supposedly protected, marine mammal rookery?

In the name of an alleged "Children's Pool," the city of San Diego sees no contradiction between encouraging tourists to view the La Jolla seals, while simultaneously revealing a calculated indifference to their suffering.

Holzer, professor emeritus at Brooklyn Law School, is a consultant to the lawyers for Save The San Diego Seals Coalition. He can be reached via e-mail at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..


Form more information, including the complete lawsuit with exhibits visit:
www.savethesandiegoseals.com

Sea Shepherd
Operation Milagro III Campaign Launch Video
Operation Milagro III Campaign Launch Video
Sea Shepherd Conservation Society is returning to Mexico’s Gulf of California for Operation Milagro III to save the near extinct vaquita marina porpoise and the endangered totoaba bass. The M/V Farley Mowat is back on active duty with the M/V Sam Simon joining the Milagro campaign for the first ti...
Sea Shepherd Investigates Whale Corpse in Sea of Cortez
Sea Shepherd Investigates Whale Corpse in Sea of Cortez
The Farley Mowat Sea Shepherd crew is called out to investigate a dead Brydes whale in the Gulf of California on November 5th, 2016 while patrolling the vaquita refuge. To help the Sea Shepherd crew to continue its work in the Sea of Cortez, including protecting the near-extinct vaquita marina porpo...
Entanglement in the South
Entanglement in the South
Operation Guardian Angel - In and around Bahia de Los Angeles, in the Gulf of California, countless marine species are entrapped in nets with little or no hope of rescue. Rosalia Tellez works for CONANP, a department of the Mexican government that acts as park rangers to enforce laws and assist in ...
Good and Bad Days
Good and Bad Days
This video follows Sea Shepherd volunteers over the course of two days. The first day Sea Shepherd locates and removes a long line from the sea; fortunately no animals were caught in the net. However, the next day volunteers find a sea lion that has been caught and died in a fisherman's net.
Operation Virus Hunter Campaign Summary
Operation Virus Hunter Campaign Summary
Sea Shepherd campaign Operation Virus Hunter saw the vessel RV Martin Sheen under the leadership of Alexandra Morton, head up the coast of British Columbia Canada to expose open pen Atlantic salmon farms and the impact they are having on wild Pacific salmon and the the surrounding eco-systems.
Illegal Totoaba Nets
Illegal Totoaba Nets
This video follows Sea Shepherd volunteers through the process of locating, retrieving and disposing of illegal nets in the Gulf of California.
Discovering Alleged Wild Salmon Dead in Fish Farms
Discovering Alleged Wild Salmon Dead in Fish Farms
August 12th 2016: Early Thursday morning the R/V Martin Sheen assisted Melissa Willie, a band councilor of the Musgamagw Dza’wada’enuxw nation, in hand delivering a letter to three farms expressing the nations disapproval of the industry. Sea Shepherd crew alongside independent biologist Alexand...
The Grind of the Faroe Islands
The Grind of the Faroe Islands
Ross McCall travels to the Faroe Islands to explore the truths behind the centuries old tradition of the brutal Pilot Whale drives.
Operation Virus Hunter: A Salmon PSA with Pamela Anderson
Operation Virus Hunter: A Salmon PSA with Pamela Anderson
Sea Shepherd Chairman of the Board, actor/activist Pamela Anderson, cautions viewers about the dangers of eating farmed salmon.
Why Just One?  Indiegogo Video
Why Just One? Indiegogo Video
Support Sea Shepherd's documentary by sharing and backing our Indiegogo campaign here: http://bit.ly/1OfvER6
Milagro Summary - English
Milagro Summary - English
Sea Shepherd Conservation Society's Operation Milagro II has come to an end. Milagro is its campaign to fight the looming extinction of the vaquita porpoise, the most endangered marine mammal in the world. With an estimate of less than 100 surviving vaquita, Sea Shepherd ships the R/V Martin Sheen...
Operation Milagro II: Vlog 15 - Good Bye
Operation Milagro II: Vlog 15 - Good Bye
Watch the crew of the Farley Mowat capture footage of illegal fishing activity with a night vision drone and pull up a totoaba net in the dead of night. This is the final vlog of Operation Milagro II!
Sea Shepherd's Ethical Research Whale Project
Sea Shepherd's Ethical Research Whale Project
Sea Shepherd's Ethical Research Whale Project is dedicated to collect samples from whales in the Gulf of California to measure levels of toxins in whales in order to determine the levels of toxins in the Gulf of California itself. Learn more at: www.seashepherd.org
Totoaba Poachers Caught on Camera
Totoaba Poachers Caught on Camera
Never before seen footage. Sea Shepherd catches critically endangered totoaba poacher in the act. The Sea Shepherd crew filmed these totoaba poachers as they were checking one of their illegal nets in the protected vaquita habitat. The vaquita porpoise is the most endangered marine mammal in the wor...
Operation Milagro II: Vlog 14 - Saving Lives
Operation Milagro II: Vlog 14 - Saving Lives
Watch‬ the routine of our crew doing valuable work in the ‪Sea of Cortez‬. We have been very effective at removing illegal fishing gear from the ‪‎vaquita‬ porpoise's habitat. So much so, that now, most of the time we remove nets and lines that are mostly empty, our favorite thing to do....
Sea Shepherd finds 3 dead vaquitas in 3 weeks
Sea Shepherd finds 3 dead vaquitas in 3 weeks
The Sea Shepherd crew has found 3 dead vaquitas in 3 weeks in the month of march of 2016. The vaquita porpoise is the most endangered marine mammal in the world. Learn more at: www.seashepherd.org/milagro2
Sea Shepherds finds a dead sample of the most endangered marine mammal in the world
Sea Shepherds finds a dead sample of the most endangered marine mammal in the world
While patrolling the waters of the upper Gulf of California the Sea Shepherd crew found a dead vaquita porpoise. The vaquita is the most endangered marine mammal in the whole world. The crew also found a Great White Shark caught in an illegal gillnet.
Operation Milagro II: Vlog 12 - This is Direct Action
Operation Milagro II: Vlog 12 - This is Direct Action
This week, the crew of ‪Sea Shepherd Conservation Society's ships The M/V Farley Mowat and The RV Martin Sheen find and retrieve an illegal totoaba bass long line from the critically endangered ‪vaquita porpoise habitat. The totoaba fish is also critically endangered. Watch all episodes at: http...
Sea Shepherd Crew Save Humpback Whale Entangled in Illegal Gillnet
Sea Shepherd Crew Save Humpback Whale Entangled in Illegal Gillnet
Sea Shepherd crew rescued a whale entangled in an illegal totoaba gillnet in the Gulf of California. Sea Shepherd currently has two vessels in Mexico's Gulf of California on OPERATION MILAGRO. Our goal is to save the vaquita porpoises, the most endangered marine mammal. The vaquita are caught as a r...
Gregg Lowe on Sea Shepherd's Operation Milagro
Gregg Lowe on Sea Shepherd's Operation Milagro
You might know Gregg Lowe from X-Men: Days of Future Past, but now watch him explain Sea Shepherd's Operation Milagro and understand why we must save the #VaquitaMarina - The most endangered cetacean in the world. Help us save the vaquita at: http://seashepherd.org/milagro2/donate-now/vaquita-appeal...
Operation Milagro II: Vlog 11 - Big Fish
Operation Milagro II: Vlog 11 - Big Fish
This week the crew of Sea Shepherd Conservation Society's ships The Farley Mowat and The Martin Sheen find and retrieve an illegal totoaba bass net from the critically endangered vaquita marina's habitat Watch all episodes at: http://www.seashepherd.org/milagro2/multimedia/videos.html ‪#‎OpMilag...
Operation Milagro II: Vlog 10 - Light up the Dark
Operation Milagro II: Vlog 10 - Light up the Dark
Actor Gregg Lowe crews with Sea Shepherd to help us protect the vaquita. The M/V Farley Mowat lights up the vaquita refuge and deters poacher from laying deadly nets in the vaquita marina's habitat. Watch all episodes at: http://seashepherd.org/milagro2/multimedia
Sea Shepherd Wildlife - False Killer Whales
Sea Shepherd Wildlife - False Killer Whales
The first video of our new series "Sea Shepherd Wildlife". This episode is about one of the lesser know large dolphins - The False Killer Whales. Learn more about these beautiful creatures with the Sea Shepherd crew. Share it with your friends. Video by Carolina A. Castro Narration by Nicole D'Entr...
Sea Shepherd Removes gillnet from Endangered Vaquita Habitat
Sea Shepherd Removes gillnet from Endangered Vaquita Habitat
Sea Shepherd Removes gillnet from Endangered Vaquita Habitat.
Operation Milagro II: Vlog 05 - Gillnet Damage
Operation Milagro II: Vlog 05 - Gillnet Damage
Join the crew of the R/V Martin Sheen as they witness the damage a gillnet can cause to marine wildlife while patrolling the endangered vaquita's refuge in Mexico.